This article comparing The Beatles’ Magical Mystery Tour and Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band, both released in 1967, got me thinking about what one hypothetical album that combined the best of both albums would look like. So as part of my Better The Beatles project, I’ve determined a track listing for Sgt. Pepper’s Magical Mystery Tour. Thirteen tracks from both albums, shuffled into an ideal song order for your listening pleasure.
- Magical Mystery Tour
- Hello, Goodbye
- With a Little Help from My Friends
- Lovely Rita
- She’s Leaving Home
- Getting Better
- Strawberry Fields Forever
- Penny Lane
- When I’m Sixty-Four
- Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds
- Baby You’re a Rich Man
- All You Need Is Love
- A Day in the Life
The cuts from Magical were pretty easy: “Flying,” “Blue Jay Way,” “I Am the Walrus,” and “The Fool on the Hill” are either too weird or too instrumental. Sgt. Pepper’s was a bit more difficult; I won’t miss “Being for the Benefit of Mr. Kite” and “Good Morning Good Morning”, but ditching “Within You Without You” eliminated the remaining George Harrison song, and “Fixing a Hole” is interesting but not interesting enough.
I pondered what to do about the two title tracks that bookend the album. Theoretically they provide the framework for both albums, but I figured “Magical Mystery Tour” performs the same upbeat and psychedelic invitation that the first “Sgt. Pepper’s” track does, so that allowed me to ditch both songs and let the album name do the storytelling.
The White Album is too long. Everyone knows this. As a public service I have trimmed down the bloated double album into one cohesive record, leaving the order unchanged but the musical integrity restored:
- Back in the U.S.S.R
- Dear Prudence
- Glass Onion
- Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da
- Happiness Is A Warm Gun
- Martha My Dear
- I Will
- Mother Nature’s Son
- Everybody’s Got Something to Hide Except Me and My Monkey
- Sexy Sadie
- Good Night
This means no “Helter Skelter” or “While My Guitar Gently Weeps” (sorry George). No “Julia” or “I’m So Tired” because those should be on a Lennon solo album. I kept “Everybody’s Got Something” over “Why Don’t We Do It In The Road” in the Long Title category because of the former’s exuberance and the latter’s being a mere half-song.
“Revolution 1” and “Revolution 9” were easy nixes because the B-side version of “Revolution” is the best and #9 isn’t music. The hardest cut was “Rocky Raccoon”, but there are still 3 other animal-themed songs, which is plenty.
I went for “Good Night” over “Don’t Pass Me By” for the Ringo tune because it’s prettier. And I ditched “The Continuing Story of Bungalow Bill” along with most of the album’s second half because they aren’t good.
Because the Internet needs more lists.
- “Octopus’s Garden” — Abbey Road (1969)
- “With a Little Help From My Friends” — Sgt. Pepper’s (1967)
- “Good Night” — The White Album (1968)
- “What Goes On” — Rubber Soul (1965)
- “Don’t Pass Me By” — The White Album (1968)
- “Yellow Submarine” — Revolver (1966)
- “I Wanna Be Your Man” — With the Beatles (1963)
- “Act Naturally” — Help! (1965)
- “Honey Don’t” — Beatles for Sale (1964)
- “Boys” — Please Please Me (1963)